I walked into the hospital this morning to be greeted by streamers and lime green (my favorite color) balloons, banners, even a pinata. My Birthday is in a few days, and my wonderful staff is spoiling me rotten today-aren't I lucky? They out do themselves every year-all the lions and giraffes and zebras are terrific-very festive and just right for the veterinary hospital. I love that they are all working together for me, as they always do.
Even though Winston has been getting raw meat about once a week throughout his life, it only takes one time like this for an owner to really understand the potential dangers of feeding raw diets. Many breeders will hail the benefits, always coming back to "wild" animals and their raw diets being so beneficial to them-better hair coats, maintaining weight, better immunity-the list goes on and on. If there is an ailment, raw diets have been reported to be the cure-all. But we know that like any food, balance is the key. Raw diets may have their place, but often are fed by people who don't understand the concept or don't take the proper precautions-and the pets pay the price.
The fact is, dogs aren't closely related to wild animals at all. They have been domesticated for some 50,000 years! Their digestive systems have evolved beyond that of a coyote or wolf, so comparing them really isn't accurate. While it is possible to feed raw diets in a healthy manner, it is expensive and very time consuming to do so. Consulting with a veterinary nutritionist is essential to determine your individual pet's requirements-it isn't enough to throw some meat and veggies and rice in a blender and call it good.
There are some very real risks to feeding raw diets-and I have seen and treated all of these, including Winston's likely case of gastritis/enteritis. Perforation of any part of the GI system from the bones fed in raw diets is immediately dangerous. I have also seen impactions of bone material when it has been properly chewed up but accumulates in a tubular organ. Broken teeth from the very hard bones is also a risk, no matter how beneficial they may be at cleaning the teeth. These problems may be minimized if the bone is ground up in a blender before feeding.
Nutritional inadequacy is very common, as I mentioned. Osteodystrophy and rickets can occur when diets aren't balanced. There is at least one raw diet that has undergone AAFCO feeding trials, Nature's Variety Instinct, so this can just be purchased and fed as a complete raw diet. If people are set on preparing their own food, consulting with nutritionists at veterinary teaching hospitals or through websites like: www.monicasegal.com and www.balanceIt.com who offer information about raw and home made diets.
The other main concern about raw diets is the contamination with pathogens. This shouldn't be a huge problem in otherwise healthy dogs or cats, but can be an issue in very young, very old or immunosuppressed animals-and people. Don't forget the risk to the humans preparing the food. A relatively unscientific survey by Consumer Reports of grocery chicken showed 80% contamination with Campylobacter, and about 15% with Salmonella - organic and free range were worse in this survey. E. coli is ever-present as well. We have many researched journal articles that support this concern too. So, just the public health issue is enough to make this way of feeding undesirable-simply cooking the ingredients eliminates the pathogens.
It is true that many toxicities have occured from traditional commercial diets due to contamination and dangerous additives-so they aren't guaranteed for safety. Still, they are less risky over all and generally the better choice for busy people who just want the best for their pets.
Peace,
DrReneigh
2 comments:
Happy almost birthday, sounds like a fun day.
The raw food advocates are very vocal and can get rather nasty at times. I just nod and go home and feed my pack their kibble with a yummy topping.
Happy Birthday! You must have a great staff!
Post a Comment